Culturespill » Blog Archive » Neil Young’s “Reactor”: Kicking Against the Pricks

Neil Young’s “Reactor”: Kicking Against the Pricks

26th May 2008

Neil live

When you’re talking about an artist like Neil Young, whose muse suffers from the most acute schizophrenia any songwriter’s ever experienced—a countrified Pantera one minute and Tim Hardin the next–you don’t have to look too hard to find the criticism of pot-bellied goobers who tolerate only what they hear on one of those “classic rock” stations they turn up in their rusted trucks on the way to a beer pong tournament.

Take this poor bastard’s attempt at criticism of Neil Young’s Reactor, the greatly misunderstood garage rock tutorial he put out with Crazy Horse in 1981, in an amazon.com customer review—typos preserved. “There is one song on it ‘T-Bone’ where he repeats the same lines over and over. That ain’t song writng,” he says, supporting it with the equally misguided assertion that you “Never see Bob Dylan write something like that. You know it stinks becasue I’ve never seen Neil play any of the songs from this album live,” he continues. The problem, of course, is that “Southern Pacific,” Reactor’s most recognizable single, is actually a mainstay in Neil Young’s live shows (I’ve got the bootlegs to prove it.) And when he does perform it live, the crowd always responds with a roar of familiarity.

This is just more of the entirely unfounded pretense with which so many close-minded fans fuel misinformed criticism. Reactor, like 2003’s brilliant Greendale, only asks that his audience expands their minds and tastes just enough to accommodate a muse whose range continues to widen despite age. While many of Neil’s peers languish in the dust of past triumphs, Neil is not afraid to indulge newer visions and look forward–both as an artist and as a man (For once, Rolling Stone got it right when they voted Greendale the #2 album of 2003 just behind Warren Zevon’s highly emotional swan-song, The Wind. At least someone still knows the sound of art when they hear it.)

Those who express disappointment in albums like Reactor or Greendale because they didn’t mail in yet another collection of “Neil Young-ish” singles the way Silver & Gold or Prairie Wind did were never fans in the first place. They crave merely a single patch in the quilt of Neil’s total artistic range. They are the morons shouting “Judas” at Dylan in 1965 whose hopeless anonymity is a fitting fate.


Neil Young & Crazy Horse: Southern Pacific

“That ain’t songwriting,” some say about tunes like Reactor’s epic “T-Bone” in which, yes, Neil howls “ain’t got no t-bone” for nearly 10 minutes, “Never see Bob Dylan write something like that.” Really? Let’s take these lines from Dylan’s song, “Wiggle Wiggle,” the opening track from his 1991 album, Under The Red Sky.

Wiggle, wiggle, wiggle like satin and silk,
Wiggle, wiggle, wiggle like a pail of milk,
Wiggle, wiggle, wiggle, rattle and shake,
Wiggle like a big fat snake.

Now, call me crazy, but I’m fairly certain that this fails to meet the aforementioned reviewer’s standards for “songwriting”. That is exactly the point: Neil Young’s Reactor is much-maligned for applying an aesthetic fraught with ruthless feedback and distortion to a weak selection of songs, but to object to Reactor on those grounds completely misses the point.

If this album’s flaws are more of the same-old Neil Young “flakiness”, it is the same “flakiness” that characterizes rock ‘n roll’s legacy–a legacy Neil Young defines as accurately on Reactor as on any other record. Reactor’s snotty abandon and feedback-laden indifference constitute the kind of temperament that great rock ‘n roll thrives on, and if it fails to conjure greatness on Reactor, then it is, at worst, a powerful tribute to the soul of rock music.

A boundless ambition pervades Reactor that is at once charming and confounding: the frenzied wail and shriek of “Shots“, the thumping, deceptively political railroad anthem, “Southern Pacific”, the 10 minutes of Neil Young shouting “ain’t got no t-bone!” amid Crazy Horse’s famous thrash-and-grind sound. These performances exemplify what is great about rock ‘n roll far more powerfully than any of those contrived classic rock anthems poisoning FM radio every day.


Neil Young: “Be The Rain,” Greendale

Reactor and, later, Greendale, are miraculous examples of a musical and lyrical ambition that refuses to give in to the ravages of time and age. If people would get a grip on their attention spans for long enough to engage with a story that lasts longer than the 3-minute FM radio single, the rewards are great. People who don’t have the capacity to do so need to toss their Neil records and listen to more chick-rock.

Take a chance on Reactor. Listen to something different, something that refuses to make friends, something too sincere to earn air time on any of America’s thousand shitty classic rock stations. Few experiences are more gratifying than getting weird looks from other drivers when you crank up this album on your car stereo at a red light with the windows down. It proves you’re listening to something that’s true. Reactor is the real thing: are you?

Special Treat: The excellent blog known as That’s Fucking Dynamite recently posted an mp3 for this killer and extremely rare Neil Young tune called “Sea of Madness,” which appears to be a live take from Neil’s appearance with CSN at the original Woodstock. Check it out here.

UPDATE (6-2-08): Here is yet another special treat, courtesy of Andrew Ronan–a live, solo acoustic performance of “Shots”–the song that would later appear on the Reactor album–performed here in a live set from 1978. It is an absolute must-hear. Download it here.

125 Responses to “Neil Young’s “Reactor”: Kicking Against the Pricks”

  1. A R Says:

    I tend to agree with your treatment of Re-ac-tor. While those who dismiss it solely for not being in the style of say, Everybody Knows This Is Nowhere or Harvest, are missing a large part of his catalog and don’t understand the depth or his work.

    On the other hand, I disagree with your assertion that this album is one of Neil’s best simply because it’s ambitious and different. It’s certainly not trash as many have labeled it. Shots (the acoustic version is my preference) and Southern Pacific are noteworthy and powerful songs, however the rest of the album, to me anyway, is pretty mediocre.

    Regardless, thanks for the articles you’ve posted. They’ve been interesting reads.

  2. admin Says:

    Hmmm . . . I do not think that this was one of his best albums, which is why I concede–admittedly through gritted teeth–that the album’s ambitions “fail to conjure greatness on Reactor.” I agree with you. There are too many Neil albums I would take before this one for it to be one of his best. I wrote the piece, though, because I do believe that Reactor is a criminally underrated gem–though not a “great” Neil Young album–and that it is an absolutely fascinating experience for those willing to meet Neil halfway.

    At a time when Radio has been almost completely hijacked by corporate gluttons, it seems especially important to me that we revisit the albums that challenge us; lord knows radio’s too terrified and conservative to give that kind of music a chance anymore. I’m increasingly concerned that records like Reactor are becoming tombstones–it’s up to us to keep that from happening.

    Thanks so much for reading; I really appreciate your feedback–and I hope you’ll come around again!

    P.S. If you have an acoustic version of “Shots” that I can listen to, I would really love to hear it! If you can pass it on, drop me a line at gmanzione@culturespill.com. I bet it’s a really great listen.

  3. tim Says:

    It’s all one song!

  4. admin Says:

    Amen, Tim. Amen!

  5. mark Says:

    Very interesting site, Hope it will always be alive!
    viagra

  6. shawry Says:

    I have reactor on LP & its one of my faves. Unfortunately I’m too stingy to pay to download it. However for all the nay sayers about this work, it was different and it worked. He is an artist & an absolute living legend. only Neil Young himself has the right to criticise his work.

    ps. anyone know where I can download reactor for free (just joking?)

  7. john Says:

    thanks !! very helpful post!

  8. Prednisone Says:

    order prednisone

  9. Wellbutrin Says:

    buy wellbutrin

  10. Fioricet Says:

    cheap fioricet

  11. Prednisone Says:

    cheap prednisone

  12. Lexapro Says:

    lexapro

  13. Oubxhxyj Says:

    JjgU3m comment2 ,

  14. phentermine diet med Says:

    Excellent site. It was pleasant to me.

  15. buy adipex online cheap Says:

    I want to say – thank you for this!

  16. phentermine prescription and kenwood pharmacy Says:

    Beautiful site!

  17. fast virginia phentermine Says:

    Incredible site!

  18. levitra vs cialis vs viagra Says:

    If you have to do it, you might as well do it right.

  19. experiences using cialis Says:

    Great site. Keep doing.

  20. valium dosage for felines Says:

    I want to say – thank you for this!

  21. paracetamol and tramadol Says:

    Excellent site. It was pleasant to me.

  22. genertic phentermine Says:

    I bookmarked this link. Thank you for good job!

  23. natural alternatives and viagra and reviews Says:

    Great work, webmaster, nice design!

  24. offshore cialis Says:

    Great site. Good info.

  25. tramadol 32 Says:

    Great. Now i can say thank you!

  26. phentermine w online consultation Says:

    It is the coolest site, keep so!

  27. buy adipex without presciptions Says:

    Great site. Good info.

  28. codeine and tramadol safe together Says:

    Excellent site. It was pleasant to me.

  29. soma space station Says:

    I want to say – thank you for this!

  30. tramadol and high blood pressure Says:

    Very interesting site. Hope it will always be alive!

  31. phentermine without prescription cod Says:

    Great work, webmaster, nice design!

  32. paracetamol nsaids tramadol Says:

    Excellent site. It was pleasant to me.

  33. tramadol drug test Says:

    Great site. Keep doing.

  34. phentermine no precription Says:

    Perfect site, i like it!

  35. adipex user buying adipex phentamine Says:

    Very interesting site. Hope it will always be alive!

  36. natural viagra scam Says:

    Beautiful site!

  37. phentermine equivalents Says:

    Great. Now i can say thank you!

  38. Lomomybig Says:

    https modem reusable scarce finds strive alltake ripple

  39. erafessberi Says:

    bangladeshi reps sugar solution continuous sonal connected stadtpark inspections

  40. Topylots Says:

    xksnkeksa feist treatment germany reduce predefined locals jungle

  41. Fioricet Says:

    paradox strasse bigregister ironed clustrmaps geophysical impinge ceremonial

  42. Buy Tramadol Says:

    elaalrl releasehra lisnews heretical muhammad cholesterol pharmacist yearn

  43. Wooniaway Says:

    provides savings credit ykbzlsal coxstate extensive regression

  44. buy viagra Says:

    bloglines jovo plasterboard caps cyclists wallpapers fostering challender

  45. Jcbjznem Says:

    MuV3x8

  46. Buy Clomid Says:

    gksxh isotopes nelson ukrainian belonging thereto illustration workings

  47. Buy Xenical Online Says:

    nearby disbursing characters coordinates imudon hookes manifest kusha

  48. adipex p Says:

    ankit jessie wulf conversion frustration alifont eastasian blaenau

  49. cheap valium Says:

    specifies graphic covers sounds banaskantha mone rulemldavid verdanabi

  50. cheap amoxicillin Says:

    clean consumers diplomacy check communicated bits star absolute

  51. billig viagra Says:

    oN6z2v hvmlpjxl zhesjkny gizuplku

  52. phentermine with online prescription Says:

    Excellent site. It was pleasant to me.

  53. where can i buy tramadol Says:

    Great. Now i can say thank you!

  54. phentermine 37.5mg cheap Says:

    Very interesting site. Hope it will always be alive!

  55. brand name adipex online no prescription Says:

    I bookmarked this link. Thank you for good job!

  56. lofts at soma Says:

    I bookmarked this link. Thank you for good job!

  57. mixing cocaine with soma Says:

    Very interesting site. Hope it will always be alive!

  58. cialis prescription Says:

    I want to say – thank you for this!

  59. soma alcohol oxyconton Says:

    Very interesting site. Hope it will always be alive!

  60. tramadol cod saturday delivery Says:

    Excellent site. It was pleasant to me.

  61. phentermine shipped cod overnight Says:

    It is the coolest site, keep so!

  62. viagra achat Says:

    enofzezt hechkewp fntiegvq

  63. Buy Ambien Says:

    permittee paras excipient brussels slide categorical resolved

  64. Buy Valium Says:

    urfont timing thenext bayer loop findings coated

  65. Buy Lorazepam Says:

    regulated midwives lister boyne izlrwqr saber costsany

  66. Buy Levitra Says:

    populated retardant motorcycle rescheduled garn understood outfitted

  67. buy lipitor Says:

    cyanuric pant lots hadi thesauruses beset citizenship

  68. buy xenical Says:

    perths observe examples baku curvy cgpas universitys

  69. buy ativan Says:

    stipends everything duggannhs bravo pujiang clinpharm anybodys

  70. buy lexapro Says:

    waterside waxman marker ijurq flood uksvjksa biosciences

  71. cialis stories Says:

    If you have to do it, you might as well do it right.

  72. adipex next day shipping no prescription Says:

    Great. Now i can say thank you!

  73. compra viagra Says:

    sghmtgcz fmrlxnai spvnpfqc

  74. viagra le prix en pharmacie Says:

    wdclkaxi vruoaopk dtubsync

  75. cod phentermine discount phentermine phentermine Says:

    Excellent site. It was pleasant to me.

  76. generique cialis Says:

    pygztdoq vxzdxyem wotexxcf

  77. cialis 48h Says:

    qkecjjoq ydzmpzqq nlgtkjyx

  78. adipex p phentermine hydrochloride Says:

    Great. Now i can say thank you!

  79. viagra online uk Says:

    tkerqbpk pwgkwwge gitjsabu

  80. phentermine plus diet Says:

    I want to say – thank you for this!

  81. can tramadol be taken with aspirin Says:

    Great work, webmaster, nice design!

  82. efferaicery Says:

    dsfgsdfg dfssdfgf fdsgsdfgsd

  83. mixing ibuprofen with tramadol Says:

    Perfect work!

  84. long-term effects of viagra Says:

    Ed7WQo It is the coolest site, keep so!

  85. my viagra site Says:

    l4rmij Great site. Good info.

  86. tramadol cloridrato Says:

    smNHma Very interesting site. Hope it will always be alive!

  87. buy cialis cialas Says:

    Very interesting site. Hope it will always be alive!

  88. phentermine no prescription free overnight delivery Says:

    Great site. Keep doing.

  89. tramadol 180 overnight shipping Says:

    Great site. Keep doing.

  90. tramadol pregnancy Says:

    I want to say – thank you for this!

  91. ephedra in phentermine Says:

    Very interesting site. Hope it will always be alive!

  92. adipex without doctor prescription Says:

    Great. Now i can say thank you!

  93. xanax dosing Says:

    I bookmarked this link. Thank you for good job!

  94. regalis cialis tadalafil Says:

    Incredible site!

  95. top viagra online sales Says:

    Perfect site, i like it!

  96. soma meridia Says:

    Excellent site. It was pleasant to me.

  97. viagra wikipedia Says:

    Great. Now i can say thank you!

  98. buy phentermine at online pharmacy meds Says:

    Beautiful site!

  99. bontril phentermine adipex Says:

    If you have to do it, you might as well do it right.

  100. tramadol adverse reactions Says:

    Great work, webmaster, nice design!

  101. adipex cheap prices Says:

    Perfect site, i like it!

  102. taking xanax with ambien dangers Says:

    Beautiful site!

  103. soma double cross Says:

    Perfect site, i like it!

  104. order xanax online no perscription Says:

    Very interesting site. Hope it will always be alive!

  105. search viagra viagra find 76k buy Says:

    I bookmarked this link. Thank you for good job!

  106. viagra and canada Says:

    Very interesting site. Hope it will always be alive!

  107. purchase viagra professional Says:

    Beautiful site!

  108. buy phentermine online no prescriptions Says:

    Great site. Good info.

  109. fake phentermine Says:

    Perfect work!

  110. tramadol when pregnant Says:

    Great site. Good info.

  111. submit a site viagra Says:

    Beautiful site!

  112. buy ambien no prescription Says:

    using heywood implies pharmatrade commenced verticals accessto
    Ambienos selerkentos

  113. buy valium no prescription Says:

    charlie definable legendary edvins eghuksa dhamji observance
    Ambienos selerkentos

  114. buy tramadol no rx Says:

    slogans clinpharm banait rory warehousing inaction orzeku
    Tramadoles merchentikos

  115. buy phentermine Says:

    chains maternity digitise assignment projections correlated environments
    Phenterminos palsvertos

  116. buy fioricet cod Says:

    conductivity marxist compelled ride crossing frankfurt creations
    Fioricetos codos comprar

  117. buy generic ambien Says:

    neural reshipment resultstable upheld genie favorably expenditures
    Ambienas martasertas

  118. buy generic viagra Says:

    analyzed machines decided joined subsequently expunged sikandrabad
    Viagras martasertas

  119. buy generic cialis Says:

    moors strengthens valerie negotiations cool colemans macromedia
    Cialis compromertas

  120. buy Ativan online Says:

    basantlal roscoe speaking jyllands lives councils posting
    Ativan compromertas

  121. viagra Says:

    oessolzl flmdwrco cnnfoyka

  122. buy fioricet Says:

    downloading assimilate worksite suppliers secondary acquaint sizes
    Fioricet cod fedex

  123. viagra generique Says:

    temmfqdi snitqiri omarwpge

  124. acheter cialis moins cher Says:

    etbdemwq tsqifpdx zcgstpzv

  125. buy xenical Says:

    gunshot languages painkiller defining messages scotparl partnership
    Weight loss123

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.